The US Supreme Court has rejected recent Republican challenges to the Affordable Care Act, upholding Barack Obama’s leading health care reform for a landslide victory for Democrats.
According to a 7-2 opinion released on Thursday, a nine-member court rejected an attempt to invalidate an attempt to repeal the Affordable Care Act, which provided health care to tens of millions of previously vulnerable Americans.
Stephen Breyer wrote the majority opinion, which was joined by two liberals, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kaga, as well as four conservatives, Chief Justice John on Roberts, Clarence Thomas, Brett Cavanaugh and Amy Connie Barrett. Samuel Alito came up with an alternative, which was joined by Conservative partner Neil Gorsuch.
On Thursday, the country’s Supreme Court ruled for the third time that it had rejected the ACA’s challenge, following its 2012-2015 judgments. The latest case was filed by a group of 18 states led by two Texas men. Donald Trump The White House submitted a similar statement in support of the plaintiffs.
The plaintiffs were pursuing a controversial “individual mandate” in which all Americans were initially required to have health insurance or a financial penalty.
His 2012 decision: The Supreme Court upheld the ACA and ruled that a penalty for non-insurance could be described as a tax, making it a constitutional exercise of congressional powers.
However, the Congress later reduced the fine to zero. The plaintiffs, led by Texas, have filed a lawsuit, arguing that the mandate is no longer constitutional and that the entire law should be overturned.
But the majority found that the plaintiffs had not been harmed, which would give them grounds to sue.
“In order to stand up, the plaintiff must ‘claim that his personal injury is justifiably reversible to the defendant’s alleged misconduct’ and will likely be remedied with the assistance sought,” Breyer wrote. “No plaintiff has caused such damage ‘quite traceable’ for the ‘allegedly unlawful conduct’ disputed here.”
After Barrett joined the bench in October last year, the decision against California և Texas was one of the first verdicts, eliminating the balance of the Supreme Court, 6-3, in favor of lawyers appointed by the Republican presidents.
In recent weeks, some progressives have called for Breyer, the oldest justice at the age of 82, to retire so that Democratic President Biden can nominate a Liberal successor while his party controls Congress. Judges of the Supreme Court are nominated by presidents for life, but their nominations must be approved by a simple majority in the Senate.
Thursday’s ruling, however, underscores that judges do not always rule ideologically. Only two Republican-appointed lawyers, Aliton Gorsukh, opposed the decision.
“Today’s decision is the third part of the trilogy of our epic Affordable Care Act; it follows the same pattern as one or two parts,” Alito wrote in his dissent. “In all three episodes, when the Affordable Care Act was under serious threat, the court provided incredible assistance.”
The ACA, often referred to as Obamacare, was signed into law in 2010. The legislation divided public opinion, but in recent years it has become more and more popular among American voters. It has been passed since the adoption of several legal challenges, including the Republican effort to repeal the law in Congress.
Democratic House Speaker Nancy Pelosi called Thursday’s decision “a significant victory for Democrats in defending people with precarious conditions against the Republicans’ relentless efforts to dismantle them.”
Sen. Chuck Schumer, a senior Democrat, responded to his comments by promising to rely on current legislation. Democrats are calling for Medicaid to expand public health insurance for low-income Americans, among other health care reforms.
“Let me be clear: the Affordable Care Act has won, the Supreme Court has ruled, the ACA is here to stay. “And now we’re going to try to make it bigger,” Schumer said. “What day?”
The White House did not immediately comment on the verdict. White House Chief of Staff Ron Klein said on Twitter: “It’s still the BFD,” he said, referring to a moment in 2010 when then-Vice President Biden was heard whispering to Obama as he signed the ACA Act. This is a big unpleasant deal. ”